#RPGaDAY2015, Day 27: Favorite Idea for Merging Two Games Into One

I’ve only heard of one other group coming up with this idea, and that was John Wick for his gaming group, so I know it’s a good idea we stumbled across. John’s version took the concept a step further than our group’s idea of using lenses, as in “we view the campaign through a different lens”.

This was actually Bo’s campaign ((Yeah, that Bo — the one who later went on to produce Tabletop.)) he was running while we were out from the gaming scene with a newborn. I think he started the game off with the d20 system, then switched over to a generic RPG system he homebrewed. ((The intent was to develop it and bring it to market, but that will never happen.)) Like I tend to do, Bo ran the game like television seasons: a major storyline through a series of episodes, then a break and retooling for the next season. We joined up in season three and he wanted to test his system in different settings with different approaches, so he came up with the idea of just playing the same campaign as viewed through different lenses. When the game started, it was somewhat based in fantasy d20 basicness. We shifted the lens, and had our next adventure in a steampunk-like world. Then we shifted again and the world was — and has always been — 1930s pulp action. Then we shifted again and we’d have a Cold War feel. All the elements changed to adapt the setting and theme: Xochipulti’s magic staff became the Hellfire Pistol, Morgan’s pirate ship became a zeppelin, and Mandi’s steampowered babbage machine became a neon-fire cyberdeck. Once the lens shifted, we went on to the next adventure. ((The antagonist of the piece originally began as a god-like force that possessed a character’s beloved. By the time we got to my lens, I cribbed from the Watchmen comic and used Dr. Manhattan’s origin for her.))

It was quite clever.

Then, a few years later (and maybe an hour and a half drive away to the north), John Wick came up with The Flux. The Flux was similar to our Lensing, but it took thinks a step further. Instead of just recasting the world under a new light, The Flux actually changed the world in-game. The game world comes to an end, resets, and recasts the same people in different positions. Everybody in this new world knew that this world was the only reality that existed — and had existed — since the dawn of time: decades, centuries of history sprung into being, even though the world was only hours, minutes old. So: we were playing World of Darkness. Now we are playing Pendragon. But — crazy thing here kids — sometimes, your Arthurian Knights have flashes to their time as Changelings in Minneapolis. They’re new characters, but not. It’s a way to explain why you’ve got a similar band of five people hanging out with each other.

Also, quite clever.

dr-manhattan-watchmen-comic-hd-wallpaper-1920x1200-5071

#RPGaDAY, Last Year: Day 27 – Game You’d Like to See Updated

So last year on #RPGaDAY, I was wondering why there was no “favorite RPG setting”. Rather than that topic, the topic was Game you’d like to see a new/improved edition of So I sort of answered the setting question with this topic. My thoughts on favorite setting were addressed this year, back on Day 21. Compare and contrast, you’ll find the same game.

Blue Planet has a great setting and a very awkwardly-implemented system. As far as the setting goes, keep it. It’s fantastic.

A quick synopsis of the setting: There’s a small colonization effort to a newly-discovered planet. Seriously bad things happen back on Earth and the colonists are written off. Nearly a century later, Earth is recovering and they send out more colonists and discover that not only did the original colonists not die out, they flourished. Unobtanium is discovered on the new planet and suddenly there’s a huge gold rush: the population goes from 70,000 to over two million in a decade. Corporate greed, people wanting to escape a hellish existence back on Earth, “natives” who want to preserve the planet — all these pressures come into conflict.

bp_modguideThe system is actually pretty good. But: while the system is pretty good, it isn’t treated right for the game. The way the system works is the better you naturally are at a thing, the more dice you roll; the more trained you are at a thing, the better the number you need to roll on at least one die. You’re a people person? Here, roll three ten-sided dice when trying to bluff your way past them. Get a 5 or better on any of those three dice and you do it. Not that good? Roll one die and beat an eight.

Where the system fails is the skill and attribute mix. This is a game where your sense of smell is as important as your physical strength, according to the attribute breakdown. It’s a game that breaks down every learned thing into different skills (over ninety in BPv2!). There are six or seven different ways to convince people to do things (fast talking, conning, bluffing, persuading, et. al.). It’s an attempt to make a generic role-playing game that doesn’t address what the players should do.

It’s my belief that a game system should inform the style of play the game is intended to do. Take a look at D&D 4e —“ everything in that game reinforces that you’re supposed to go into large battle zones and fight monsters. Take a look at Atomic Robo — the skill list points play in a certain direction as do the skill modes you take to create your character. When there’s four basic skill groups and one of them is SCIENCE!, that says something about how the game is supposed to be played.

78943There is no guidance in Blue Planet’s system that says what type of game this should be. Why does my bartender in a resort town that gets in over his head with a terrorist group have a skill rating in zero-g maneuvering, pharmacology, and shepherding? Are those skills really going to come into play in this game?

Also, there’s no way to quickly generate NPCs in the game. Each character is created through a lifepath: Where were you born? What type of childhood did you have? What did you do after you got out of school? So if you want to bluff your way past a bouncer at a club, you have to ask where was that guy born? How was his childhood like? And on. And on.

Oh, but a few tweaks to the skill and attribute list is really all that is needed to drive play towards a design goal rather than “go play in a big sandbox filled with water” Give me a sandbox, but put some walls around it.

The other cool thing about Blue Planet as a game is it gives the complete game to you. The timeline goes up to a certain point and from then on, what happens on Poseidon, stays on your Poseidon. This is fantastic and something I would strongly advocate for in a Blue Planet v3.

0-CATERS-Diver-Takes-A-School-Photo-01-jpg_215006

#RPGaDAY2015, Day 26: Favorite Inspiration

I find a lot of the #RPGaDAY2015 prompts a bit confusing — rather, hard to grasp exactly what they’re driving at. Favorite inspiration for your game is one of those. It’s like asking a writer where he gets his ideas from. ((The correct answer is “a small warehouse in Schenectady, New York”.)) I don’t get the concept for an adventure/mission/whatever from any one place. Even if I were to take the plot of Hamlet and set it in my game on Mars in 2132, I’m going to be adding so much more from things that I have encountered and experienced over the years. It’s hard to get a good answer out of this one, and that’s without assuming I can recall the genesis of moments in those decades of gameplay.

What spawned the idea that the drow and evil races was merely propaganda by the mind-flayer-controlled rulers of the D&D game world?

Where did that idea of cities being living, slumbering giants contained by magical circles formed of ring roads and highway bypass loops in my Dresden Files game come from?

Why does Bruce Campbell keep showing up in my games? ((That one’s pretty easy to answer. He’s a cool guy.))

the_adventures_of_brisco_county_jr_186x250Let’s go with Bruce Campbell for a second. See, when I was running Shadowrun, 2nd Edition, we had the television show The Adventures of Brisco County, Jr., integrated into the game. In Brisco, there was this time-travelling villain, John Bly, who came to the present of the 1880’s with three magical orbs, and that drove the overlying plot of the show. In Shadowrun, there’s this whole Fourth World thing from thousands of years ago when there was magic and now it’s the Sixth World, where magic came back, so it’s not too much of a stretch to say that an evil Immortal Elf ((A big thing from Shadowrun 2. Everyone famous in history? An elf from the Fourth World, living in the non-magical Fifth, disguised as a human. All over the place.)) went from the far past to the far future and then to the relatively recent past and then — in the show, Bly explodes or gets sucked into an orb or something — to more closer recent past and then tried to get his hands on the surviving orbs to do Something Nasty.

So yeah, there’s an inspiration. A confusing one, but still.

I suppose that’ll do.